Friday, July 10, 2015

Blogging Brotherhood: Episodes 57 & 58

 
Author's Note: Because I am a horribly weak person, I cracked and finished the last eight or so episodes of the series in one sitting (plus being in grad school I wanted to get this done as soon as possible). I attempted to outline my thoughts at the end of each episode, but that quickly fell off as I blew through the ending. With that in mind, from this post onwards they will be written with the knowledge of how the story ends. I'll try and keep everything as authentic to my initial thoughts as possible, but there is honestly so much stuff happening in these episodes that it's hard to get everything down.

Episode Fifty-Seven: Eternal Leave

The battle for a nation’s soul descends into chaos. Bradley unleashes death on those who dare engage him. Beneath Central, the one responsible for the Fuhrer’s creation unleashes something far, far worse.
 
Oh good god. This episode. After getting blindsided by the first two in this season, this one shows up and decides to take what's left of my fragile heart and rip it to pieces.

We start out with Olivier and Izumi bullying information out of that one bearded official who is, honestly, a big damn idiot for continuing to elaborate on the corrupt generals' plan. Does he not see their faces as he keeps trying to justify his actions? He's only pissing off Izumi and Olivier the more he talks, especially when he pulls out the whole "One is All, All is One" spiel.  Izumi smashing him with the shoe was great, though. Almost cathartic in some ways, I think.


Then they conveniently find a secret passage that's been left open in the aftermath of the attacks in the Fuhrer's office and follow it down. I'm assuming that was for Bradley's use, but I don't remember the show ever specifying that it was there in the first place. It could have, I'm not sure. It's hard to remember a lot of things at this point.

Olivier redeems herself a little more here, as well. She cares about her men a lot more than she lets on and isn't afraid to sacrifice herself for their sake and that of the mission. On the flip side, her men have enough loyalty and trust in her to obey her when she says to get out and leave her behind if they have to. I love how she interacts with Izumi, too. We don't get to see two grown women have a conversation much in this show, so it feels a bit refreshing. Not to mention that I fully believe Olivier has compassion underneath her icy exterior. When Izumi tells her about her experience with human transmutation, she doesn't criticize her or call her a fool or do anything that you'd expect. She listens and then says she saw something similar when she first met Edward.


It's great that they bring that whole scenario up again because it fills us in a little bit on her character as a whole. I got the impression that there was something going on in her head back when I first watched that episode, but I didn't think it was admiration for what he was doing. One of the wonderful things about Edward is his absolute devotion to the people he loves. It's what carries him through a lot of this story and motivates him on many occasions, such as when Olivier ordered him to give her information regarding Sloth. I think it said a lot, too, that this frigid and stoic general was moved by his steadfast refusal to answer her questions even when she had no idea why he was insisting on staying silent. She could see his desperation in his eyes and that clued her into the possibility of him not answering her for the sake of someone else. He wasn't a dog of the military and he wasn't acting like a soldier. He was acting as a person willing to throw away his own safety for the sake of another.

Switching over to Edward, Scar, Hawkeye, and Mustang, there's even more going on.

I have to admit, I liked watching these four dorks work as a team. Scar's palled around with so many different people at this point that he could probably be helpful with anyone. The four of them together is basically having the four most badass characters doing what they do best: fight.


As is typical, the show answered my earlier question about what the heck happened to the failed candidates for kingship as well as where they came from in the first place. Apparently they were abandoned babies that they took in and used as candidates, kind of like an orphanage if orphanages ran countries and brainwashed/psychologically ruined children. Once Bradley had been chosen as the new Fuhrer, that horrifying gold-toothed frog-man took the "leftovers" and used them more or less as his minions. They have deliberate and calculated actions as Scar points out (and are a genuine threat to all four of them), although whether or not those soldiers have minds of their own is unclear. They're drawn with pretty brain-dead features and they don't say anything, obeying the gold-toothed man on command.

The banter between Hawkeye and Mustang never ceases to disappoint:

Hawkeye: You keep leaving your back wide open, Sir.
Mustang: Well I've gotta give you something to do.

Mustang, stop. You are not that cool.

They reveal in this episode as well that the five laboratories were five "points" on the city-wide transmutation circle, which is activated by the gold-toothed man (GTM) while they're down in that...ambiguous underground location (seriously, where the hell are they, again?). He activates the circle and Izumi, Ed, and Al are transported...somewhere. We don't know where specifically.

The fighting between Bradley, Ling/Greed, and Fu is epic. So fast and awesome. Lots of cool tricks and moves on everyone's part. I love the creepy way Bradley's eyes turn red and everything slows down right before he lands a blow on Fu. There's a monster-like quality to it.


Ling and Greed are becoming more and more interchangeable; the line where one starts and the other begins is starting to blur. When Fu goes to launch himself as a human bomb against Bradley, Greed is right there with Ling when condemning him as a foolish old man. It says a lot that Fu and Lan Fan would be so willing to lay their lives down for him. Ling's ideas on leadership are as noble as they were back in season two, and Bradley comments on his refusal to let any of his people die again. You can see the direct juxtaposition between Bradley's corruption and Ling's selfless sacrifice.

We have another character to bite the bullet. At least Fu is given an honorable death by way of Buccaneer, who lands a lethal blow to Bradley, finally. I have to admit that it was a clever move on his part, especially since I was under the impression that he was too close to death to perform such an attack. Bradley gets a nice blow to his all-seeing eye courtesy of Ling/Greed, and I'm hoping that that means Bradley becomes a far easier combatant to face off with.

Episode Fifty-Eight: Sacrifices

"Mustang must make a difficult choice: will he break alchemy’s greatest taboo? Or will he watch the person dearest to him die? Meanwhile, it grows ever more difficult to discern where Ling ends and Greed begins."

These episodes have, for the most part, managed to keep the three or four different story threads that are weaving into the larger narrative pretty straight, but I will say that, starting probably back with Oliver and Alex, this is where the fights tend to drag themselves out. This episode is the finale for the Greed/Ling and Bradley fight which has been going on for...three episodes now? My issue is that, after a while, I start to get annoyed because these fights, in reality, aren't taking three episodes-worth of material to get to completion. They're spread out over several episodes because of all the other plotlines that need to be taken care of in the span of twenty-four minutes. I wouldn't say that this is a huge problem, but it's noticeable, especially when the rest of the series flew by the seat of its pants up until this point. The constant re-treading also makes the events of each episode start to blend together in my head.

Ling and Greed are getting more and more intertwined, even though Greed is the one that still occupies a larger level of control over the body they're sharing. I don't think Greed is telling people to stay out of the fight because he wants to do it himself; he wants to protect them and prevent them from getting hurt judging by his joint reaction with Ling to Fu's attack against Bradley. I like how this change has been gradual (as gradual as they can make it in the limited amount of screen time either character has had since Greed first took over) and does feel authentic. Greed is seeing value in Ling beyond his body and Ling appreciates Greed's power and can see through his outward desire to "have everything." If Greed truly just wanted to "rule the world," he wouldn't have bothered to carry out Buccaneer's request of defending the gate.


What I think is probably the most interesting element of this part of the episode, though, is the fact that Ling's servant does die and there's nothing he can do to save him. His desperation to find help and then the realization that, even with all of the power of a Philosopher's Stone inside him, he still isn't powerful enough to save someone, is heartbreaking. His statement of: "I finally gain immortality and I can't even save one of my subjects," is where his idealistic perception of ruling is shattered. You can't save everyone. Death in inevitable and irreversible, which then ties into two other facets of the show: Mustang's desire to protect everyone he loves at all costs and the Elric's initial belief that they can cheat death and resurrect their mother. The interpretation would be that it's foolish to believe  either of these things are possible.

(As a quick side note, what the heck was up with the guy who shot Ling in the head? Where did he come from? Why did he shoot him? And it's not like he played any significant role, either. He shoots Ling/Greed, grumbles about him being a monster, and then dies. Ling/Greed heals. Nothing happens. What was the point of including that scene?)

We can kind of see the juxtaposition of this idealism with Olivier who, after hearing about the death of Buccaneer, is clearly upset and devastated over the loss...but she isn't willing to let it render her useless. She recognizes the inevitability of death. She honors her men, but doesn't lament them. "Love for the dead is pointless. We fight to keep them alive, that is all," is what she's said before.

The next plot line jumps to Ed, Izumi, Hohenheim, and Alphonse, who have all been gathered to be "sacrifices" for the grander plan that Father has in mind. I have to admit that the...bizarre image of Hohenheim inside the newly christened version of Father is a little ridiculous. Hohenheim's limbs are sticking out in several directions, including his head, and Father looks like he eats a little too much cake or maybe has a few more beers than he should.


I have no idea how Father managed to wrangle Hohenheim into his body in such a fashion, but I don't think I honestly wanted to see it, anyway.

Aside from the freaky image of him swallowing a full-grown man, though, I don't find this design to be particularly intimidating. In fact, when I first saw it, I laughed. He looks like a a chubby dude in a body suit with eyes painted on it. There's nothing commanding about him in the slightest. I prefer the human "rubber bag" that he previously occupied to this...thing.

But I do love how Ed openly insults him and he doesn't even react.

This is also where I think the thematic differences of Brotherhood and the original FMA can be seen really well. In the original series, the focus was on the Elric brothers and their journey. They never escaped the spotlight of the show, regardless of how many other side stories were weaved into the larger narrative. Brotherhood doesn't take that same narrow approach; it's got a stable of characters that are all important to the plot that need as equal amount of attention to be paid to them as possible otherwise things won't make sense. With all of the juggling the writers have to do to make sure everything works out, this whole section of the story--arguably the most important--is pretty sidelined in a lot of these later episodes. The earlier scenes with Ling/Greed and Bradley take up a good third of the episode's running time and both Oliver's scene and this one are stuck sharing a second third.

Because we all know what happens in this particular episode that's the most memorable: Hawkeye.

I knew something was coming with her because if you pay attention to the title cards, they tend to highlight characters that are either going to play a major role in the plot of that episode or have something drastic happen to them. Based on what happens here (and all of the dozens of other moments where Roy steps in to save someone he cares about i.e. Gluttony's attack on Hawkeye and Fuery), I was anticipating the GTM to have one of his minions fix a sword at her throat and give Roy the ultimatum of "Perform human transmutation or we will kill her."

I was not expecting them to actually slit her throat right there.


And poor Roy--you can see how much he's struggling to make up his mind about whether or not to give in to what the GTM wants him to do. He's never going to escape having Hughes as a leverage point with his enemies, which sucks, because it's not like he can control the fact that his best friend died. For a brief moment I thought he was going to let Hawkeye die...but of course that can't happen. He gave orders for none of his men to die, remember? I knew that was going to come back into play.

However, this whole scene makes me question Mustang's dependence and loyalty to Hawkeye (and vice versa). Earlier, I made the comment that their relationship seems to be leaning more in the direction of romantic attraction than purely platonic affection. At that point in the story, it was still a little ambiguous, and even now there are people who believe that their relationship is strictly a professional one. I'm not going to question anyone's interpretation--the way you see something is your perspective and that's fine. But frankly, I don't understand how you can't see any romantic attraction between the two of them.

I may end up writing more on this later because Hawkeye's character is a bit of a conundrum in general, but this little tidbit here regarding her use of the pronoun "あăȘた" or "anata" in the Japanese version/manga should be enough to make you pause. I've seen varying sources of information and lots of people bicker over it (native Japanese speakers and non-native alike), but the general consensus seems to be that the word should a) probably just be avoided if you can b) never be used when addressing someone of higher rank than you and c) has a connotation of familiarity because  wives frequently use it to address their husbands. One of the ways you can translate it is as "honey" or "dear" or some other term of endearment.

I'm just saying. We lose that in the English version, but I'm not convinced that Arakawa was trying to be ambiguous with their feelings, especially considering that Roy returns the informality even though he was addressed in what would have been considered an extremely rude and presumptuous fashion by someone who is, socially and professionally, his subordinate.

My point in all of this is that the two of them exhibit what could be considered, under ordinary circumstances, an unhealthy attachment and dependency on each other. Riza is the one that gets thrown under the bus for this a lot, but Roy is just as guilty. And while I'm not going to sit here and comment on that larger issue (because that is a whole new post in and of itself), I will say that, for me, the only convincing explanation for that type of co-dependency--in this context--is romantic love.

Also, a shout-out to Travis Willingham's spectacular acting here. Mustang tends to have some clunky lines every now and then (probably in part due to translation and animation limitations), but everything said in this scene is delivered with natural, emotional conviction.


They do finally address the notion of Roy being a sacrifice, which was mentioned way back in like, episode 17 or 18 and then...disappeared. The gold-toothed guy realizes that they're short a candidate and it's a damn convenient coincidence that Mustang is there. It's implied that he had always been one of their candidates and that the GTM would have had to go get him from the radio station where he thought he was hiding out had he not, you know, popped in for a visit. There was also the issue of whether or not someone had to open the portal in order to be considered a sacrifice, which is clarified here, though it's done in a stilted, awkward way in light of the fact that Mustang's candidacy was ambiguous for twenty-something episodes even without the caveat of him not ever having opened the Gate. As a result, the GTM's explanation almost sounds meta in its delivery--like the men he's referring to are the writers who forgot that they were lacking their fifth sacrifice. It's a little giggle-worthy but also makes me scratch my head.

We're left with Mustang appearing to agree to do the human transmutation as Hawkeye lays dying a few feet away. Talk about a cliff-hanger.

General Thoughts

As much as I did enjoy these episodes, I have to admit that things are beginning to verge on the side of complicated and weird. I'm finding more plot holes than I did in the earlier episodes and the dragging out of the fights is getting on my nerves.

Friday, July 3, 2015

Blogging Brotherhood: Episodes 55 & 56

 Episode Fifty-Five: The Adults' Way of Life

"A rebel victory is imminent and hope takes hold among Mustang and Armstrong’s troops. Central’s forces teeter on the brink of collapse - until their fallen leader returns to take control."

Oh man, the banter that starts out this episode was much appreciated. Roy is such a douchebag sometimes, and I'm on Edward's side in this case. Hawkeye had already talked you down by the time Edward and Scar showed up? I don't think so.


I like the little moment that Hawkeye and Scar have here, as well. Hawkeye knows that Scar was the one that really brought Mustang back from his decent into madness and she thanks him for being willing to do what he did. Like everyone else, she's drowning in guilt over what happened in Ishval and doesn't expect him to care much about her gratitude, but Scar's grown enough at this point that he is able to recognize who the real enemies are--and Riza sure as hell isn't one of them.

The focus of this episode is on Olivier, Alex, and--surprise!--Sig and Izumi. Olivier and Alex are STILL trying to take out Sloth when we switch over to their part of the narrative. How many episodes has this dragged out now? Four? Part of the issue is that there are so many things happening right now that getting to everyone is taking time. That's another danger of a having a massive cast--you can't get to each character as often as you'd like because other things and people take precedent. As a result, Alex and Olivier end up looking a little...inept and I started to wonder how they hadn't collapsed already from exhaustion since it feels like they've been fighting Sloth for three days. By the time Izumi and Sig show up, I was relieved. They were finally getting some substantial help.

There were a couple of neat things about this chunk of the fight, though. Central soldiers are clever enough to grab one of Sloth's chains and use it to prevent him from striking both of the Armstrongs, even if it's only for a few seconds. Alex and Olivier also refuse to run away when they are told by everyone else to do so. Alex in particular makes a point to say he won't, with a flashback of him breaking down in Ishval hammering his position home.

Then Izumi and Sig show up and it takes them like, three seconds to beat Sloth down. The look on the Armstrongs' faces is great:


Naturally, Alex and Sig strike a friendship in seconds as they bask in the beauty of their own gigantic muscles.

The four of them take out Sloth after what feels like the ten-thousandth time they've impaled him. I guess either there's a limit to how many times a Homunculus can die before they stop rejuvenating themselves or the...stalactite-thing that he's impaled with pierced the stone inside his body. Regardless of how he died, I'm glad he's dead because that fight was getting tedious.

Izumi tells Alex and Olivier that she knows the Elric brothers and that it's likely they're running around somewhere in Central. There's a moment where Alex and Olivier share a glance and for the life of me I can't remember why. Is the Elric's presence a problem? Was there something they were supposed to be doing or going after? Or are they staring at Izumi? Grr...this is the thing I hate about long-running shows; I can't remember anything without a damn graphic organizer, chart, and character list. I brief flashback to something would be helpful. Sigh.

Anyway.

Hohenheim and Father finally get their reunion. Father is a lot colder and emotionless than I was expecting. He was never a very...animated person (no pun intended), but he did have more vibrancy in past scenes than he shows here. They also do a great job of showing how much power this guy has, as he spends the duration of his fight standing still and flinging things at Hohenheim rather than moving around. He's got enough skill and strength to take on a healthier, younger man without much effort. Or, the Stone does. I don't think his body is holding up too well.


Hohenheim makes a point that I brought up earlier: Father had always mocked the notions of family and community, and yet he takes the time to separate the sins within his human form and create a family of Homunculus. They call him Father and they sarcastically refer to each other as brother and sister. Hohenheim claims that Father's mocking of the human need for community was a cover for his own jealousy--he wants the very thing he claims to find meaningless. Father claims that he would never stoop so low as to be jealous of human, but I'm not buying that. If Envy is supposed to be a part of him, then it makes sense that Envy's jealousy of humans would come directly from Father's own sentiments.

By the end of the episode, the "rebel" forces have taken most of--if not all--the main gates at Central Command, and not for one second did I think that celebration was going to last. You could see Bradley walking in the background in the scene where Al, Marcoh, Heinkel, and Yoki are trying to get the wheel of their car out of a hole. Why they don't just leave it and keep walking, I have no idea. I have to admit, though, that when Bradley's voice came up over the phone, I actually jumped. That was so well-done, with the sudden silencing of the background music and the way Ed Blaylock says, "I'm back."

I'm left with frustration and worry now with what's going to happen.

Episode Fifty-Six: The Return of the Fuhrer

"Central’s forces fight with renewed vigor following Bradley’s return, and the Fuhrer himself enters the battle. His first opponent is an armored tank. His second foe is even tougher."

As it turns out, Hohenheim has been carrying the souls of everyone that the Stone inside him absorbed and all of them are still very much alive in the spiritual sense. I find it mildly creepy that he's been walking around for what's probably close to a century with those people inside of him; not just that but he talked to each of them and got to know who they are. Which...looking at objectively sounds kind of ridiculous, since I'm not sure how you'd "talk" to someone whose soul is hanging out inside your own body. It's one of those things that I guess I should chock up to fantasy and not think about it too much, but at least Brotherhood does a good job of building to that point. They've dropped hints here and there--like with Envy's giant monster form--that the souls consumed for Philosopher's Stones aren't actually dead; the concept didn't just drop out of the sky. So it works on some level here.


Then they all start blowing Father up from the inside and it's great. Too bad that's not the end of everything right there.

Yes, apparently Father long ago "evolved" so that he no longer needed his body and instead has an actual physical form that he can use to walk around in the world. This part kind of confused me, because if he didn't need the body as a container to house him, why the heck did he keep it for so long? It was obviously getting older and growing weaker. He could have disposed of it and used his real shadow-person form and saved himself the trouble of dealing with a withering body. Maybe it was for appearances? Better to look like a commanding, powerful human than a creepy Homunculus? It would be nice if that was clarified.


This show is also developing a thing for people being eaten, and I'm not altogether okay with that. Father consumes his old body like it's an afternoon snack. That's disgusting.

Meanwhile, Bradley arrives back at Central Command and absolutely rips the place to pieces, people and tanks alike. I'd like to know what's in his sword, because that sucker can cut through anything. He spends a good bit of time chasing a tank through the palace (if creatures can eat their own bodies in this world, I guess it's only natural that a tank would have no issue blowing through a building like it's a paved road) before arriving at the roof where he meets up with Falman and Buccaneer and the rest of the Briggs soldiers still stationed there. Buccaneer gets the crap beaten out of him by Bradley, but somehow manages to stay alive. Then again, he's from Briggs; I shouldn't be surprised by his stubborn refusal to die.

I have to admit, Greed is continuing to surprise me. I'm not sure at this point whether or not he's becoming more heroic or if he's amused by the fighting and using it as a way to get in on his own bug against Bradley. Based on the behavior of all of these Homunculus, which has nuances and layers since the characters have a lot underneath their surface, it could be either one. Greed was always a bit of an outlier; his actions were based on his own interests, regardless of whether they were good or bad. Now, though, he seems to be gravitating more towards humanity, and I wonder if that has anything to do with the fact that he's sharing a body with a human instead of possessing it for himself. Ling certainly has influenced him--in decisions that he makes or the fighting techniques he uses. I wonder what will become of both of them as this show keeps going.


The fighting in this episode is great. Well-animated, well-structured, dynamic, and interesting. Fighting in shows can be hit or miss with me, but everything that Bradley and Greed throw at each other here is entertaining as hell. It's so fluid and fast-paced. Of course, the real magic behind the success of a good fight scene is that you care about what's going to happen to the people involved; and the show has done a fantastic job of making sure I'm invested in all of these characters. I never thought I would be so concerned about Buccaneer's fate until I thought he had died. Oh, and I think it's hilarious that Bradley stabs him with his sword and that sucker stays in his gut because his abs are so impressive. Even Bradley is like, wut. It was clever thinking on Buccaneer's part, since it stripped Bradley of his preferred weapon and (theoretically) made it easier for them to attack him.

Falman gets a great opportunity to shine here. He was the member of Mustang's team that got the smallest amount of screen time and I had the least level of attachment to. Since I've come to the conclusion that this show can read my mind, they rectify that a little by having him step up to the plate and lead everyone while Greed takes care of Bradley. Even if his first reaction is to whine about it:

"But we've hardly got any men left here, what the hell am I supposed to do?!"

And then he orders everyone to take a machine gun and basically obliterate the men that are coming up the stars toward them like walking targets. Haha what. That's ruthless.

This episode sees the return of Old Man Fu, who locates Ling by using Greed's chi. For an old man, he's got some moves. This exchange also takes place and it's got to be one of the best lines in this series so far:

Greed: Thanks for the help. You really saved my ass.
Fu: I wasn't trying to save your ass. I was saving the body of the Young Lord.
Greed: Hm. Well, it's same ass.


Only this show would be able to make a butt joke in the middle of a crisis and it still work.

On a final note, Fuery and Ross have in interesting conversation in the hallway of the radio station. Thanks to Bradley's return, they were forced to throw Olivier under the bus to save their public face and protect Mustang. Bradley and his men will find out rather quickly that they weren't on the side of state after all, but the impression that they are gives them at least a little bit of time before the army comes for them. Fuery makes a comment about how it would be strange for Bradley to kill everyone in the station with his wife present, and Ross says that she doubts he has any real attachment to her or would care that she saw anything. I'm not so sure--his reaction when Greed broke into his house with Selim and his wife around looked pretty genuine, and the way he and Selim spoke about her leads me to believe they at least have respect for her. I don't think she'd be disposed of or allowed to witness something as brutal as execution so haphazardly, if at all.

Then again, who knows. Maybe Bradley is just really good at playing a loving husband. 

General Thoughts

After two intense emotional episodes, this action-oriented set was a welcomed relief. What's great about this show, though, is even when the episode is more centered on fighting and action, there's still plenty of other things going on that keep you invested.

At this stage in the game, this blogger is getting tired. It's been an incredibly long journey, I'm about to dive into a rough patch of schoolwork, and I have got to finish this series within the next two weeks. I'm hoping to fly through as much as I can over the next few days, but we'll see what happens.

Thursday, July 2, 2015

Blogging Brotherhood: Episode 53 & 54


Author's Note: Because Netflix decided, for whatever reason, to remove the last 13 episodes of  Brotherhood from their site, I'm switching services. Hulu has all of the episodes I need, but they're only available in Japanese (I've watched it this far in English; making the switch now would be annoying). So instead, I've gone the route of signing up for Funimation's free two-week trial just for the sake of having (legal) access to this show in English. But for crying out loud, you'd think with something as well-known and popular as this that more places would have it to stream. Netflix is generally not very good and they came out on top this time with the most amount of episodes available in Japanese and English. Anyway, that's why a good portion of the images now have the "Funimation" watermark on them. 

Episode Fifty-Three: Flame of Vengeance

"After a startling radio broadcast grants Mustang’s forces the advantage over Central’s troops, the Flame Alchemist unleashes the brutal power of burning hatred in the battle against the killer of Maes Hughes."

Oh yes. Oh yes. The opening scene to this episode (and therefore season five) is awesome. It isn't exciting, per se, but it does showcase something that I thought was a lost cause, at least for a while: Fuhrer Bradley's wife's testimony manages to convince people that a) Mustang is a hero and on the side of the state and b) that there was a conspiracy to overthrow the government. They used Bradley's disappearance and all of the chaos in Central to frame what's happening as they want people to see it. It was clever and satisfying to watch. At the same time, I do feel bad for Bradley's wife; she doesn't play any major role in these events, is completely innocent in the whole endeavor, and has no idea her husband and son have been lying to her for...well, the entire time they've been a family. Which I'm guessing is a while.

There is one thing that this plan made me think about, though, and that's the possible commentary that the show could be making on uprisings, rebellions, and government in general. It may not seem obvious initially, but if you stop and think about it, Mustang and the forces trying to take down Central aren't doing things a whole lot different than their opponents. People in Central were deliberately kept in the dark about Bradley's disappearance by the ones in charge, which is depicted as a bad thing. Yet who was responsible for the train exploding and therefore his disappearance in the first place? Technically, it's our heroes (well, more specifically it was Grumman's idea and I don't know how much or how little Mustang or anyone else was expecting it), and they're not making any attempts to clarify that. Bradley's wife thinks there's a plan to overthrow the government, which is true, but the people that are the ones behind everything are being heralded as heroes, like Mustang. They aren't out-right lying in most cases...but they're also not being entirely truthful.


I mean, look at what Grumman says to himself as he listens to the broadcast: "Brilliant play, Mustang! Taking advantage of the Fuhrer's absence and using his influence any way you'd like to suit your needs. And invoking the name of justice at that. Let's keep our fingers crossed that the public accepts it." Ross and Breda even have a somewhat sarcastic discussion about justice, in reference to her statement she broadcasted over the air. It's pretty clear that no one is all that concerned about justice in this case; they're concerned about eliminating the corruption, regardless of what it takes to do so. Being "just" isn't a major factor, and if it does show up, it's by happy coincidence.

My point, I guess, is that it's a good thing we know Mustang and all of the other players in this are genuinely good people, otherwise Central would be so freaking screwed.

The guy who gets on the phone with the Central general and convinces him that the station is under attack by Mustang and his men is fabulous. That entire scene, really, is funny. Everyone is laughing their heads off while that guy--who I'm guessing is maybe a station manager?--totally goes overkill on the drama and then just cuts off the line. I love it.

Denny's face, too, when he hears Ross' voice over the radio is precious:


There are a couple of other funny moments in this episode, like when that one general says, "They'd need a tank to breech the main gate" and--oh look!--they have a tank. They also used Olivier's mansion to assemble and hide the tank, which is just...I don't even know. Clever? Ridiculous? Awesome? Could be any of those. Mustang also makes a stupid joke about how the last time he and Hawkeye were in that underground room, she was crying over him. She responds by saying, "The last thing I'm gonna do is start crying for you now. Water makes you useless."

You just got burned, Roy. And she didn't even need flame alchemy to do it.

Of course, there's also the fact that Mustang and Hawkeye stand in the doorway doing nothing while Mustang processes in his head what the mannequins are and how they could eliminate them. He isn't even standing in any kind of ready position; he's just hanging out, thinking, while Hawkeye at least has her gun pointed and is prepared to move and everyone else is desperately trying to keep themselves from getting eaten. Then Roy blows them all up with flame alchemy, because it really took him several minutes to come to that decision. He does do it in a way that prevents anyone but the mannequins from getting hurt, so I guess his daydreaming went somewhere.

May shows back up, leading Envy right to where Ed and Co. are. She gets yelled at by Scar for coming back and not returning to Xing like he told her to, she starts crying, and I can't tell if that's meant to be played for laughs. Given her dialogue, the way Monica Rial plays it, and the fact that the camera switches to Envy's bored expression for the duration of her sniffling makes it hard to determine if that was, indeed, meant as a joke. She does seem genuinely upset, yet somehow I can picture Monica saying those lines and then bursting into laughter once the take was done. Whatever. It bothered me that Scar yelled at her, but it's such a minor detail that it doesn't make much of a difference either way, I suppose.


And then...once Envy is in the picture, this episode takes a direction that I don't even want to remotely joke about, because it's...it's really not funny. I said in the last entry that this show doesn't pull any punches when it comes to violence, but I think what's harder to swallow is the utter rawness with which they treat trauma and emotional wounds. Envy's confession to murdering Hughes is one of the more haunting and unsettling things in this show, and it isn't achieved by him reenacting the moment or describing in detail what happened or how he did it. As he tells Mustang after he re-creates Hughes' wife's form:

"Tell me who the real moron is here, because I don't think it's me! I prefer to use that term for someone who falls for a cheap trick like this. Ha-ha! You should see your face! Ah, you're not gonna believe this, but that was the same look on Hughes' face when I shot him! The utter shock, the dumb confusion! You can see every emotion he felt as his own wife shot him! It...was...great!"

You can tell everyone in that room is either horrified into silence or ready to rip out his throat, and most of that is because of the twisted nature of both how excited Envy was to have killed Hughes and the fact that he basically inflicted psychological torture on him before doing it. I don't blame Mustang for the intense, burning hatred he feels towards Envy.


Even so, Mustang's transformation after Envy's confession was one of the most uncomfortable things this show has depicted. Maybe it's because I've always, always had a soft spot for Roy and Riza's characters (even back in the original) that this freaked me out, but even with that bias I can't help thinking that other people felt the same way. We basically get a repeat of Lust's fight with Mustang, only this time Roy quickly devolves into his own brand of monster. He gets so intense and so violent and so angry that Envy runs away from him. Envy pulls himself together and retaliates, but he eventually runs and hides because he takes too much damage.

Not to mention that Envy's voice actor makes the scenes where he's being incinerated all the more painful to listen to. Look, I don't like Envy. But damn the noises and screams and dialogue that he shrieks in this episode gave me chills. It's disturbing, regardless of Envy's guilt. What's worse is that Roy is not prepared to show any mercy. He's enjoying ripping him apart. Scar was right--that if he continued down the path of revenge and retribution, it would destroy him. I don't think it would take much more than obliterating Envy for that transformation to become permanent with Mustang. Edward and Hawkeye know that. They're going to intervene. They have to. Otherwise, the person who had every intention of becoming the Fuhrer and protecting the people he loves will have to be removed.

And I don't want to see that happen.

The last scene of this episode has Hawkeye pointing a gun at Mustang's back, which I'm assuming means that one of them is Envy. The smirk on Hawkeye's face leads me to believe that's Envy, especially considering that the previous shot had Envy seeing her in the tunnel.

Episode Fifty-Four: Beyond the Inferno

"As Envy writhes within the firestorm unleashed by Mustang’s vengeful rage, Hawkeye must take drastic measures to prevent the Flame Alchemist’s hatred from burning out of control."

Good god. Last episode was bad; this one was brutal. 

FMA has always kind of said "Screw you" to my emotions, so watching an episode that's sad isn't unique or new. No, this episode goes beyond making me sad and instead takes my heart and bludgeons it with a baseball bat. There were also some moments that made me feel things I'm not so sure I'm comfortable with.

We open with a pre-credits scene that's a flashback to 1909, the end of the Ishvalan War. We've been given a small amount of information regarding Hawkeye and Mustang's past already; this adds more detail and fleshes out their relationship even further. It isn't too long, but it does bring back into the spotlight Riza's back tattoo that I had actually been wondering about as of the last four or five episodes. They introduced it a while back as her father's research that he entrusted to her to keep safe. Mustang is the only one who knows about it. It's unclear whether or not the tattoo was how Mustang learned flame alchemy in particular or if that was, in fact, taught to him by Riza's father. This scene does explain why her back is scarred--I thought that it had maybe been shot because someone attempted to kill her, but no, she asks Roy to burn the tattoo off of her back so that no one can ever use flame alchemy again.


What this opening scene sets up (or, more than anything adds to) is the kind of relationship that the two of them have. It's more than just an "Oh yeah, you're the daughter of the guy who taught me everything I know about alchemy" kind of deal; Hawkeye trusted him to straight-up mutilate her back without actually killing her. Mustang would give up his own life for her sake. For better or worse, the two of them are inseparable.

Which then carries us into the rest of this episode.

I was wrong about Envy being disguised as Hawkeye; it's the other way around. She makes a statement about how when it's just her and Mustang, he calls her by her first name. It's a bluff and Envy falls for it, but it made me stop for a second because I was pretty sure I had never heard Roy say "Riza," ever.  My assumption is that this is 90% a Japanese thing and 10% a habit rooted in an official army tradition. It makes at least a little sense to Americans in this context.

(Side note: The Japanese tradition of formality would also be why Al always calls Ed "brother" rather than by his first name. English doesn't have a single word for "older brother," and calling him that for the duration of the show would sound unnatural to English speakers. That's my understanding, at least.)

God, that whole scene where Envy is dumb enough to attack Hawkeye and throw her to the ground with Roy proceeding to scorch the ever-loving shit out of him is...stomach-turning. Mustang has already done this with Lust, but this is different: With her it was a calculated move, his only intentions being to wipe out what he saw as the enemy. Here...here Mustang is losing it, and I swear I thought Hawkeye was going to cry as she watched him throw blow after blow at Envy. It takes her longer than I anticipated to stand up to him, though I suppose that comes from going so long obeying his orders. I think she wanted to trust him, wanted to let him make the decision to be merciful on his own, but that clearly wasn't going to happen.


I have never been more relieved to see Edward, with the possible exception of when he first appeared after that brush with death last season. He brings Scar with him, too, which is so full of irony I don't even think I need to explain it.

Then there's Envy. 

I understand that Envy is despicable. He's twisted, disturbed, violent, and has killed numerous people without remorse. He's awful. I don't like him. I have little sympathy for him. I hope he dies and never comes back. These are all the things I know to be true about the character and my feelings towards him.

But I'll be damned. I wanted nothing more than for someone to show that piece of garbage some mercy. Despite everything he's done, despite all of the atrocities he's committed, Envy didn't deserve to die like that, pleading for his life while being crushed in his helpless chameleon form under Mustang's boot. It wasn't right. Part of it may be the fact that Envy's voice when he is reduced to his true form is... kind of cute and vulnerable. I may be showing my female colors here with this, but there's no way on earth that I couldn't show mercy to someone (or something in this case) who squeaks when they're stepped on and has the voice and breathing pattern of a child. I'm sorry. It wouldn't happen. The icing on top of that cake is the fact that Envy is crying. Those giant eyes are pleading with Mustang not to kill him. As much of a front as he tries to put up, I'm convinced that Envy is truly terrified at this point and those tears are real, even if he doesn't want to admit it to himself.


Edward demonstrates a level of maturity here that I think rivals many of the adults in this show. He stands up to Mustang not out of defiance, but because he knows what's happening and he's doing his best to prevent it. Everyone in that room has felt what Mustang has and they all know first-hand what hate can do to a person. Ed's willing to let Mustang attack him, with the caveat that he will fight back. And unlike Mustang, Edward has enough control of himself and compassion left that he wouldn't seriously hurt Roy.

Scar has one of his best lines when he tells him: "Are you becoming a beast? Giving in to it's passion? You can if you want to. I won't stop you from giving in to revenge. What right do I have to stop someone from taking vengeance?  But still...I shudder to think what kind of world a man held captive by his own hate would create once he becomes its ruler." You can see the complete 180-degree turn his character has made, as he's finally realized what his own thirst for vengeance created in him. He knows better than anyone what hatred can do to a person, and he managed to find a way to stop himself from going down that path without being able to return. And he's right--what good could come of a country if its ruler is controlled by his own hate? Everything they've worked for, everything that Mustang wanted to protect and defend, would be obliterated.

Thank god they make him see that.

But the feels don't end there. Oh no. As Mustang starts to come down from his high, Hawkeye tells him that if she had to kill him, she would. She'd do it and then take care of whatever was left, and without even a shred of hesitation she says she'd end her own life in order to keep her secret of flame alchemy from being found. I don't know about anyone else, but I think that's pretty damn bleak. This woman, who is capable of so much on her own, is so loyal to Mustang and so determined to prevent any more evil from entering the world through her, is willing to kill herself for the sake of others and from her own despair. I don't know if that's admirable or shameful.


Her admittance of it, though, I think is what really brings Mustang back. He launches a burst of fire down another tunnel, which I guess is supposed to be symbolic of him purging his anger, and then the next shot of his face has his features returned to normal. His response of: "I can't let that happen. I can't afford to lose you," also poses an interesting question: Is there something more than friendship between them? They've made jokes about a possible romantic attraction all throughout the show (including the previous episode), and with the way he treats her (he values all of his men for sure, but I think Riza has a special place) you'd get the impression that there was more there than platonic friendship. And yet...I don't know. I'm not saying it isn't possible, but honestly I think that they are too dedicated to their job and their country to ever act on those feelings if they're there. I'm still rooting for it in the back of my mind, but I wouldn't be surprised or even all that disappointed if nothing comes to fruition.

The final punch to the gut in this episode is the realization Edward makes about Envy. I had always wondered why he was named Envy, since out of all the Homunculus he acted the least like his name. Ed hits the nail on the head when he says that Envy's jealous of humans. He's jealous of their resolve, of their capacity to love and forgive and keep fighting even when they're knocked down. The Homunculus may have unbelievable power, but they're nothing in comparison to humans when it comes to the soul. Envy tries to incite anger in Ed, Scar, Mustang, and Hawkeye not because he is amused by their anger or bitterness as he claims; it's because he is incapable of forgiving or loving or having compassion and all those things he sees in them as they sit there. The sight of humans--especially humans that are enemies-turned-allies--working together and demonstrating those characteristics infuriates him and exacerbates his jealousy.

He basically verifies Edward's claim when he says, "I'm a Homunculus! How can this pipsqueak kid see through me?" Edward has the unique position of being the first human to understand why Envy is so twisted. He's broken through all of Envy's walls and motives and humiliated him by figuring him out. Yet, even with that, Envy still respects Edward: As he dissolves after pulling the Philosopher's Stone out of his body, he says: "Goodbye...Edward Elric." It's the first and last time that he refers to Ed by name.

OKAY.

I'm going to rush through the last bit since this entry is already embarrassingly long.

Oliver and Alex continue to lead men in the fight against Sloth, and Alex almost gets his skull bashed in. Olivier, as expected, has no compassion for her brother's plight and insists that he will survive or not be worthy of the Armstrong name. I have to assume that her brutal attitude towards Alex is the best way to motivate him, since it's after she says that that he picks himself up and takes out Sloth. I guess she's what it would look like to have violent, unrelenting optimism.



This episode leaves us with a brief appearance of Izumi, who I hope gets to kick some serious ass and do a lot of cool things. It's been a long time since she was around. 

General Thoughts

These episodes have thoroughly ripped through my soul, and I imagine it's only going to get worse from here. Please let this show have a happy ending, otherwise I'm going to crawl into a hole and weep for eternity.

Wednesday, July 1, 2015

Blogging Brotherhood: Episodes 50-52

Episode Fifty: Upheaval in Central

"Mustang leads a ragtag assault force of hardy northern troops--and welcome faces from the past--against Central's defenses."

The first half of this episode is so much fun. Several different people come back into play, from Rebecca to Havoc to even Lt. Ross. Ross' return was the most surprising, although it probably shouldn't have been since she played a significant role earlier. It's nice to see her again, regardless. Hawkeye's friend Rebecca is also a lot of fun; she's slightly eccentric but not obnoxious and I love the fact that she's driving a cutesy, friendly ice cream truck as a cover for transporting munitions. That's hilarious. As I figured, Havoc is working behind the scenes and was responsible for getting Ross back into the action as well as supplying them with the weapons they needed in the ice cream truck.


(Side note: That bear looks a lot like a character from Happy Tree Friends...which just makes it all the funnier. If you don't know what HTF is, please look it up.)

The downside to all of this is that I'm having trouble keeping track of plans and people and what everyone is supposed to be doing and when. Part of it could be my habit of listening but not processing information, but at this point in time we've got so many characters running around that I have to practically make a list of everyone who isn't Ed, Al, Mustang, Hawkeye, and Hohenheim to know who they are and what their job is. Although in comparison to what could have happened, this massive cast is still quite well-balanced. Everyone is given something to do. No one feels they're hanging around for the hell of it. Unfortunately, it means that I have to go back and watch certain portions or episodes or conversations to keep track of it all for my own sake.

That may or may not even be everyone.
I am also a complete idiot and had NO IDEA that the guy from last episode's post-credits scene was Denny Brosh, the goober that was Ross' partner back in season one or two. They didn't do a whole lot with him, so I can excuse myself some there, but I did feel pretty dumb when he ranted about Mustang being evil and then it clicked who the heck he was.

Backing up a bit, I was right about Mustang storing a battalion inside of the Armstrong mansion. He used it as a place to hide all of the men that are attacking Central, and I'm assuming Olivier knew they were there. I mean, how could she not? The mansion may be huge, but putting an entire battalion in it would still mean stuffing a lot of people in a single space.

Olivier herself is proving to be a weird character, because to be perfectly honest I'm not convinced she's a hero anymore. I wouldn't call her a villain, but she's neutral in the larger sense. She's more concerned about her country's survival than actually "being a hero" or "doing what's right." She attempts to take control of the Central forces through coercion, which doesn't work, and then it turns out that her Briggs' soldiers swooped in and obliterated a bunch of those men. She stabs a general in the arm with a knife and then shoots another right in the face. It was cool and everything, but I can't help but feel like there was a distinct reason that Mustang and his men weren't killing anyone, and she kind of puts a damper on whatever point they were trying to make. Then again, Olivier is operating outside of Mustang's direction, so it's not like that could be blamed on him. Not that the Central forces would care; they'd still see it all as treason, anyway.

Ugh, I'm rambling. Olivier confuses me. I think about her too hard.


Although Olivier's decision to murder that general brings up another point that I was thinking about as I watched: Despite it's pre-teen/teenage boy target audience, this show really does not give two shits about the violence it portrays. I don't mean that it's excessive, because to be honest I wouldn't even classify this show as all that violent, but when it does choose to show violence and bloodshed it doesn't hide behind blackouts or alternate camera angles. You see people get shot, stabbed, punched, etc in real time. The only shots they don't explicitly show are the ones done for effect. Within this episode, one character tells a Central troop that he's lucky that he isn't a Briggs soldier, otherwise the shot to the Central troop would be a kill shot. Major Miles told Edward outright that he was going to kill Kimblee and his men several episodes back.

It creates an interesting juxtaposition with the two leads, who refuse to kill under any circumstances. In comparison to some of these soldiers, Ed and Al are practically saints. Mustang holds back his flame alchemy, but I get the feeling that not killing anyone is more about strategy than it is for the sake of preserving life. I'm not saying Mustang would be all for killing more people; I'm just reading his and his troops' actions as calculated rather than solely based on morality.

On an unrelated note, I had a feeling that the tapping Pride was doing on Al's helmet last episode wasn't arbitrary. If he had been knocking it rhythmically it wouldn't have raised a red flag, but if you go back and watch how he hits it...it sounds like Morse code. It's even more pronounced in this episode, to the point where you can tell something is up before they make it obvious. I guess that means Ed and Hohenheim are in for a surprise when they find him underground, since by this point Father must know they're coming.

I love how Edward manages to make a smart decision that also caters to his ego with those guards in front of the Fifth Laboratory. It was probably more practical to throw them off rather than just attack, but of course that was more about Ed's ego than anything else. Because he's a goober.


Also, Hohenheim's statement, "That was a mean thing to do" is really funny. And it's funny because of the way John Swasey says it along with the fact that a massively powerful alchemist and walking Philosopher's Stone said the word "mean" like he's ten years old.

The last big thing to happen in this episode (as there were many) is that one of the generals is releasing that army we saw a few episodes back. I thought they had already been in operation before and were stored away for the time being since they weren't needed. But no--these things are untested, unpredictable, and...creepy as hell. I'm sure the next episode will bring lots of wonderful imagery along with it, ahahaha...


Episode Fifty-One: The Immortal Legion

"Ed's crew faces a horde of ravenous mannequins, abominations powered by human souls."

If I had to summarize this episode in one word it would be "disturbing."

This immortal army is given quite a bit of screen time, with their introduction involving the devouring of two people, one of which is the guy who let them out. Here's a pro-tip: Whenever someone says, "But we haven't finished testing ____ yet!" DO NOT let it out. Whatever it is. I don't care if it's a giant bunny made of cotton candy and filled with the laughter of small children. It's going to destroy something. Or, in the case of these undead things, eat people.

I find it kind of strange that these soldiers--which are powered by souls and Philosopher's Stones--would be after people. There isn't much sense behind it, unless the idea is that consuming people powers the Stone within them and therefore the more they eat, the more powerful they become. But it's not like they're absorbing people into their bodies; they're tearing open their necks and literally eating them like vultures.


In general, this army was just all kinds of bad ideas rolled into one.

Ed, Scar, and their gang end up back where Al and Mustang fought Lust, and as a bonus Barry the Chopper is still hanging out down there in all his broken, rusting glory. The legion of zombie people find their way down there and Ed transmutes the door so they can't get out and terrorize the rest of Central. The downside is that they're all stuck in that room with the zombies who keep pouring in through the open door on the other side of the room. I've gotta be honest and say that watching them fight these zombies is a little amusing, if only for the fact that it's unbelievable how much of a mess they're all in because of one idiot. It's that sort of situation where you think, "Wow, things are so dire right now that I can't help but laugh because I'll burst into tears otherwise." Also, it's hilarious when that one chimera guy flings one of them over his shoulder and yells, "Get. OFF!"

Sloth makes a return as well, and Olivier has the pleasure of facing off with him. There's something inherently humorous about Sloth's character, as he doesn't do much or say anything of note, but when he does talk it's clear that he doesn't give a crap about who he's fighting. He's just doing what he's told, as fast as he can, so he can go back to sleep.

Sounds like every college kid I've ever spoken to.

Olivier holds her own for a while, but then THANK YOU LORD because Alex shows back up and is a complete badass. Alex always was a tough guy, he just chose to hold back because I think he prefers peace to violence. Alex saves Olivier's life and--at least for the moment--they seem to be on slightly better terms.


You have no idea how hard I laughed at "Mustang is fleeing in an ice cream truck. Seal off all the roads!" Good grief, that is fantastic. Nothing like a powerful alchemist to be marked by something so juvenile and ridiculous. My guess is that he's going to transmute the truck into something else, and hopefully it's as amazing as an ice cream truck.

The biggest element of this episode, though, I think is Al's confrontation with Pride and Kimblee. At this point, I'm crossing my fingers that someone takes Kimblee out, because I am sick and tired of his stupid face showing up everywhere. I was correct about Al and Pride not being locked up for the duration of the action. There was too much potential there to keep them holed up for long.

In any case, Heinkel realizes (after, you know, listening to it all day long) that Pride is using Al's head to tap out Morse code, like I mentioned in the previous episode. I thought he was sending out messages to Father about what Ed's plans were, since he was right there to hear a good chunk of them, but he was actually sending out his location. And that's of course how Kimblee found him and blew a hole in the giant dirt hamster ball to let him out. In typical Kimblee fashion, he attacks Heinkel and I was really disappointed that his character was going to be eliminated so unceremoniously, but it turned out that he wasn't dead.


Al gets some more great moments to shine here, and he's actually fighting for the duration of it. Not to mention he's really clever--he managed to fool Pride and get away, using the dust cloud from his alchemy to hide himself and the severely injured Heinkel. He demonstrates his level of resolve and, I think to a large degree loyalty, by refusing the leave Heinkel behind even when he tells him to do so. Al is literally crawling to safety (since he detached his body from his legs to escape Pride's grip) while dragging a grown man who is close to death. That's how selfless Al and Ed are. As Heinkel tells him: "You're still determined to help another person even when you're falling to pieces yourself." What's especially great is that selflessness doesn't feel forced; it falls in line with the type of people that Ed and Al have been written to be. It's easier to see it in Al, I think, but Edward's concern for others is as legitimate, if a little less obvious.

I have to say, also, that I'm quite impressed with the level of continuity in this show. Heinkel still has the Philosopher's Stone that he picked up several episodes back when Kimblee abandoned him. I had forgotten about that, which isn't altogether surprising, but I doubt many other more observant watchers remembered it, either. Heinkel is able to convince Al to use the stone regardless of the fact that it's filled with human souls. Al's now looking at it's usage as a way to let the people inside fight back against the injustice.


As a final note, May is back and I got a kick out of watching Envy flip around in that jar as she ran from the zombies. I'm a bit disappointed that he got his body back, and not because it means there's another person that they're going to have to take down (again); nah, I'm disappointed because seeing Envy as a little green chameleon-looking thing is way more fun than his human form. May is a damn good fighter, too, and watching her kick the crap out of those zombies was great. Not to mention the animation for that is smooth and exciting.

This episode introduces our last full-blown opening and ending (I heard that there's a different OP/ED for the last episode, but I'm not 100% sure and am trying to avoid spoilers). The opening is visually awesome. There are lots of great images, like the entire cast of heroes that moves across the screen and the sketchy, creepy style for the Homunculus. The image of Trisha opening her arms while light shines from behind her is a stunning shot as well. It's...probably one of the only somewhat uplifting ones. Lots of white in the visuals, too which, according to this website, means death and mourning for Eastern cultures and Japanese people (the site specifically says that a white carnation symbolizes death).

So that's encouraging.

There's one thing in particular that I'm concerned about, and that's the possibility based on the images of Mustang either drowning or falling and Hawkeye crying that Roy will die. And as I said in my last post, I'm not prepared to deal with that. I'm crossing my fingers that those shots are misleading.

SID's "Rain" is okay. It's not jumping out at me as one that I'll want for the iPod, but "Golden Time Lover" didn't, either and now it's one of my favorites. Funny how that works.

On the downside, I think the ending is hella lazy and boring. Most of the visuals aren't interesting and Shoko Nakagawa's "Ray of Light" is "meh." You'd think with the last ending they'd go all out and have some neat things going on, but 90% of it is stills and the other 10% is minimal animation. It just screams lazy to me. I know that sounds harsh considering it's the fifth one and by that point the staff probably didn't even care, but still. Go out with a bang, not a whimper, you know?

Episode Fifty-Two: Combined Strength

"With a Philosopher's Stone in his possession, Alphonse fearlessly engages Pride and Kimblee."

HOLY CRAP.
OH MY GOSH.
KIMBLEE IS DEAD.
HE'S OFFICIALLY DEAD.
 ...
Excuse me while I go weep tears of joy.

I'm sorry to those who liked Kimblee, but I honestly could not be happier that he's out of the picture. His presence irked the hell out of me and he felt more like an extra appendage for the Homunculus and Father than anyone genuinely useful. Plus he was an asshole.

But I'll get to that in a minute.

Rewinding to the beginning of the episode, the animation for the fight scene is incredible. It's so dynamic and fast-paced and intense. Again, Al demonstrates not only his great fighting skills but his quick-thinking. He tricks Pride a couple of times during both parts of the fight (before and after he gets trapped inside the cone Al makes with the Philosopher's Stone). Given that Pride is an old-as-dirt and intensely powerful Homunculus and Al is a teenage boy...that's impressive.


The one thing I will say in Kimblee's favor is that he brings up a good point during his conversation with Al while Pride's contained in the cone. Al laments that it's unfair he and Edward are forced to choose between saving everyone and getting their bodies back, and Kimblee's response is to point out that there is another option: They can get neither. They can save no one and never get their bodies back. It's bleak, and definitely something that pit stain would say, but there's no denying that he's right. As optimistic as Al is and Winry tries to be, Edward had a point back in Risembul when he said it wasn't likely that they could succeed with what they were trying to do, at least not in entirety. Something would have to be given up, if you looked at the situation with any level of practicality or reason. Of course, Al is still clinging to the idea of an exception to the rule and then using that rule to rewrite what's possible. I'm not going to say that this won't happen, since I'm counting on this story having a happy ending, but the show had better find a way to pull it off that doesn't come across as lazy or nonsensical (kind of like the previous show did).

I do have to give credit to the writers for making use of Yoki. His and Marcoh's involvement in taking down Pride and getting away was nice, and it's made all the better by the fact that Yoki was the one who ran over Pride with the car Kimblee drove. He may not have done much damage, but it was a hit and it gave them time to get away.

Now, about Kimblee's death.

As much as I was rooting for it, when the moment did arrive I was actually quite shocked, for two reasons: One, they have Heinkel bite his throat and pierce his windpipe rather than blowing him up or stabbing him (and personally I find the animalistic nature of the act to be far worse than either of the latter). Two, Kimblee doesn't come back from it. He dies. Al makes no attempt to help him and there's no last-minute miracle to save him.


It's unclear whether or not Kimblee would have been able to do anything for himself had Pride not decided to eat him. Considering that it was a pretty mortal wound, I doubt it, yet this show has a way of surprising me even when it shouldn't, so there's that. I'm definitely disturbed at the notion of Pride devouring someone that isn't a Homunculus and if it was anyone else I'd feel some sympathy. Honestly, though, I've got no remorse for that creep. He can have fun in hell.

The only thing I don't get is why Pride refused to attack Kimblee when he was fighting Al. Al held him up as a shield and Pride withdrew his...weird shadow-spear-things and he even noted that doing such a thing was counter to Pride's character. So why do it? Was it a ploy to convince Al that he cared about Kimblee? Because if it was, what did he gain from it? I thought he genuinely did want to keep him alive, but once he decided to eat him that theory went out the window. Maybe that will be explained later. I don't know.

We also find out that Sloth is the fastest of the Homunculus because irony. I do like his reaction to when more people run into the room where he's fighting Olivier and Alex: He sighs and puts his hand on his head like, "Good grief, I'm so over this 'work' thing." He's so different from all the other Homunculus who enjoy everything they get to do. Sloth couldn't care less. Somehow I ended up feeling kind of bad for him when Alex skewers his head to keep him contained.


Alex pulls his character out of the shadows with this episode, too. He had been a fading presence for a lot of this series, whereas in the 2003 anime he had a lot more to do and didn't come across quite as...fluffy as he does in Brotherhood. Despite his fluffiness, though, Alex will bring out the muscles and brutality when someone he cares about is threatened. Olivier may act like a creep to him, but Alex loves her and is willing to throw himself in front of Sloth--to the point of dislocating his shoulder--to protect her. Of course, it doesn't take long for them to start bickering again, but hey, at least there were a few genuine moments of sibling affection for me to enjoy.

Envy gets into a squabble with May in the tunnel where the previous episode left them. Envy is kind of an idiot and consumes all of the zombie creatures to gain their power and Philosopher's Stones, which means that he takes away the extra threat to May. I think she knows that and that's why she pushes his buttons. The more she pisses him off, the more zombies he consumes out of rage and the less she has to fight. She's also still apparently looking for immortality. It's been so long since that was brought up that I thought to myself, "Wait, she still cares about that? That's still a thing?" Seems to me like she's more concerned about helping Amestris than getting immortality, even if that's not what she's telling herself.

Ed and his gang are still occupied by the zombies in this episode, though they discover that they can attack their legs and it immobilizes them to a large degree. But even with that knowledge, there's still a butt-ton of those things and it's pretty obvious that everyone--including the chimeras--are getting worn out.

Then, of course, we have the last shot for this season which has Mustang and Hawkeye breaking into the room through the alchemy-covered door and Mustang making some smarmy comment to Ed about always making a mess and needing some help. Which, I mean, they do. Bad.

I'd also like to point out how awesome the animators make those two look:


It's like something that would be on an action movie poster.

(As a follow-up to my amusement with the ice cream truck, Mustang turned it into a meat truck. Which isn't as funny as I was hoping, but when you think about the fact that there are a bunch of people inside of a meat truck...it kind of makes a joke about them being indispensable without, you know, actually making a joke. Or maybe I'm the only one that sees that and finds it clever.)

General Thoughts on Season Four

This has probably been one of my favorite seasons, although at this point everything is beginning to run together so saying that may not actually mean anything. The closer to the climax we get, the more action there's going to be and the more shocks I'm sure I'm going to get. I really love how they've built this plot up slowly and methodically without making it feel like it's dragging its heels. 52 episodes in and nothing feels wasted. There have been no fillers, and that's an accomplishment for such a lengthy series. It's also managed to balance its cast well--something equally as impressive when you look at how many active players we have at this point.

Now the trick will be ending this series in a way that doesn't feel forced, overly sentimental, awkward, or nonsensical. I'll give it some leeway considering that there have been a small number of shows that I've watched which manage to have successful, coherent endings. The sheer scope of this story makes it a challenge to bring full circle. We'll see if it can appease me rather than all-out impress me.

Whoo-hoo I am down to the wire now! 13 episodes left and I AM READY, DUDE.