Showing posts with label Articles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Articles. Show all posts

Saturday, April 25, 2015

Frank Miller is Writing Another Batman Story Because That's Really What We Needed


You know, there are decisions made by people in this world that confuse me, maybe anger me, or even cause me to lose faith in whoever it is involved in the stupid-decision-making. Most of the time I can shrug them off and move on since, honestly, it's not like my world has been turned upside-down by someone thinking that drawing Jason Todd's helmet like this is a good idea:


And then there are some decisions that are so mind-bogglingly asinine that I'm left staring at my ceiling and wondering if maybe I somehow ended up in a parallel dimension where everything is backwards and nothing makes sense anymore.

It's been confirmed that Frank Miller is going to write, alongside Brian Azzarello, a third and final sequel to his Dark Knight Returns series called "The Master Race." Because when I think of Batman, race is definitely a topic that shoots straight to the forefront of my mind.I'm going to be pretty honest here: I can't stand Frank Miller. I hate his writing. I hate his characters. I hate that the artwork for DK2 looks like a five year-old with schizophrenia drew it. I hate that none of his female characters ever have anything redeemable about them because they're too busy shoving their tits in the reader's face. And I hate that this man continues to get work despite not having produced anything worth reading on the Batman front since 1987's Year One.

Maybe I'm destroying my "comics cred" or "Batman cred" or whatever by saying this, but honestly I think that The Dark Knight Returns and Year One are both okay at best. His characterization of the Joker in TDKR is unsettling in a way that makes me want to throw up my lunch rather than shiver with excitement and interest. The pacing in that book is also an issue, as he dedicates entire pages to drawings of anchormen/women dolling out exposition and using them as a platform for his pseudo-criticism. Year One commits the sin of just being kind of boring, with a Batman that's melodramatic and reads like a weird fanboy impersonating him than the actual character. Oh, and we can't forgot Gordon's totally necessary affair with Sarah Essen.

They're not terrible, and I would recommend reading them if for no other reason than the fact that they ARE iconic and important benchmarks in Batman's history. The fight between Batman and Superman is actually well done and engaging, but apart from that, there's nothing that's altogether worth praising in either of them. At least, not to the extent that everyone else does.

Once you get into DK2 territory and beyond, though, Frank Miller makes it clear that he's been abducted by aliens and they modified his brain in such a way that prevents him from thinking and writing and acting like a normal human being. Also, it may have regressed him back into a thirteen year-old boy mentally.

In DK2, Batman turns into a deranged, self-centered creep that treats everyone around him like their brains are made of mashed potatoes. Superman's character is turned into an incompetent fool. Carrie Kelley is sexualized and given a costume that would allow her to fit in nicely with The Cheetah Girls. Dick Grayson turns into a villain and makes himself look like The Joker because why the hell not. But perhaps the worst element of that book--aside from the atrocious artwork that really does make a case for that alien abduction re-writing his brain so he actually thinks that the world exists inside various MS Paint effects--is that Batman isn't even in the book for most it and instead Miller toggles back and forth between Carrie, The Atom, and various other Justice League members.


Then there's All-Star Batman and Robin the Boy Wonder. Just...I...I can't even fathom how this book got the green light, other than the editor at the time took one too many shots before reading the script. At the time, DC was planning on releasing a series of "All Star" books for their major characters that were designed to go back to basics and tell stories that wouldn't be bogged down by continuity. All-Star Superman went on to be considered one of the greatest Superman stories ever written, All-Star Wonder Woman and All-Star Batgirl never saw publication for various reasons, and All-Batman and Robin...became infamous for all the wrong reasons.

In ASBAR, Batman is a psychotic killer with the intelligence and perspective of an eleven year-old boy. He kidnaps Dick Grayson on the night that his parents are killed, mentally and physically abusing him for the duration of the comic. Alfred has strange romantic feelings for Bruce. Vicki Vale is a horny columnist who doesn't need to be in the story at all and at one point Batman and Robin paint themselves and their entire house yellow so that Green Lantern won't be able to use his ring on them. Oh, and the Justice League get more space and dialogue than the title characters do.

The whole thing is poorly written, badly paced, and showcases everything I hate about Frank Miller and his writing in one neat little unfinished 12-issue story:

You have the over-sexualization of women with Vicky Vale:

...in which it is of vital importance for her to be sauntering around her apartment in nothing but her underwear with giant glass windows behind her as she dictates a news story about the size of Superman's junk versus Batman's. Because superhero penises are what I want to read about when I buy a book called "All-Star Batman and Robin."

Oh, and let's not forget his commentary to Jim Lee, the artist for the book and the source of the only redeeming quality ASBAR has (the artwork):


Miller also seems to think that Wonder Woman's status as a feminist icon means that she is supposed to be a man-hating lesbian who views men as a lower species and therefore refers to them as "sperm banks:"

The trench coat is also mandatory.
Then there's his dialogue, which makes every character sound like they just walked out of Sin City. They're overly aggressive, melodramatic, and crude. And that's when they're not repeating themselves three or four times like they have some kind of disease and need to do so before feeling okay with continuing whatever it was they have to say.

His blatant mischaracterization of everyone is also front and center here. Batgirl has the mouth of a truck driver and Black Canary has become an Irish bartender with a uniform rivaling that of a premiere stripper. Green Lantern is an incompetent idiot and only marginally more intelligent than Superman, who is treated like Batman's bitch and runs across the world to bring a specific doctor to the hospital for Vicki Vale because Batman said so:


Not to mention the way Bruce treats Dick like he's some kind of annoying, unneeded appendage even though he's the one who roped him into becoming his sidekick in the first place:



This also includes demanding that he call himself Robin instead of Robin Hood, which Dick picked out, and forcing the twelve year-old to eat rats in the Batcave for survival rather than, you know, using the billions of dollars that he has to buy the kid a damn Happy Meal.

And let's not forget the subtle but frightening references to pedophilia that pop up every now and again:


Last but not least, the PURPLE. EFFING. PROSE:


 "...dear Gotham calling to me like a sultry siren." What.

His version of Batman nowadays reads a lot more like a crazed fanfiction than anything literary, or even intelligent.

I could write an entire novel on why this book is a stain on humanity, and maybe someday I'll tackle that project. But for now, my main point:

For me, this entire thing screams desperation, but I don't understand why DC should be feeling desperate. After all of the criticism that was launched at them for their New 52 reboot, they seemed to be getting at least a little bit back on track. Convergence is bringing back, at least for two months, a bunch of old characters and universes for fans that haven't seen them in three years, and their post-Convergence lineup of comics looks amazing with Starfire getting her own book along with Cyborg and Martian Manhunter. They have several major blockbusters in the works that are generating all kinds of press. There's also that marketing push that DC and Mattel are working to put together that's focused exlusively on their heroines. DC is showing signs of improvement, that they're interested in entering the year 2015 along with everyone else.

So then why do they feel the need to let Frank Miller get a hold of Batman again? What has he produced as of late that isn't a complete disaster? Why would they let a man who returned to fame because he managed to acquire Meme Status with his "Goddamn Batman" line go anywhere near another Batman title, especially given how successful Snyder has been with his Batman stories?

And worst of all, why are we rehashing a book that was written over thirty years ago when there is so much new material and directions to explore with the character?

My best guess is that there are still rabid fans out there who are stuck in the 80's and would love nothing more than to see a "classic and revered" writer come back for one last hurrah. There must be SOMEONE out there who doesn't care that Miller is a has-been, washed up writer with nothing new or non-offensive to wrestle out of his deranged and crumbling mind.

Whatever the case may be, I'm hoping that this book bombs so hard that DC is forced to tie Miller up with some industrial-quality rope and shove a few pairs of socks into his mouth before tossing him into a broom closet in the darkest, emptiest corner of their office building.

Then I will be satisfied.

Wednesday, April 2, 2014

6 Myths About Skin Picking Disorders

This past week, I had the opportunity to spend several days at home from college while on Spring Break. As I sat at the kitchen counter chatting with my brother and his girlfriend, my dad came in and noticed the box of band aids lying near the cabinet where we keep all of our medications and first aid materials.

“The band aids are out. Well, we know Kayleigh’s definitely home.”

I laughed awkwardly, trying to brush his comment off.

He sighed and put the box away, then grabbed his coffee and left the kitchen.

I know that I use a boatload of band aids on a regular basis. At certain times, I can fly through an entire box in a week. But the reason for my dad’s comment was not the fact that I seem to have little regard for how much money band aids (don’t) cost, but the reason behind why I use them: I have dermatillomania, or a compulsive skin picking disorder (SPD).

It’s likely that I’ve had this disorder from the time I was a child, since I have distinct memories of picking my skin as far back as elementary school, but my parents never looked into it as a serious problem. In fact, dermatillomania is a relatively new illness to make its way into the realm of psychiatric disorders, so it’s not surprising that they thought very little of it. Even now, as more and more people are beginning to realize that this is more than just a bad habit, there are still many out there that don't understand how this disorder works.

So in the interest of informing the general public, I’d like to clarify a few misconceptions that surround this illness and hopefully educate those of you out there who may know someone with dermatillomania or possibly have it yourself.

 
1. Skin picking is just a nasty habit. In some contexts, it can be. It’s normal for people to pick at their skin every once in a while, such as when they see a pimple or dry patches during the winter. What separates dermatillomania from just a habit is the fact that it is constant and takes place over a length of time, eventually causing damage such as discoloration, infection, scarring, and, in severe cases, a need for skin grafting. Dermatillomania is classified as a Body-Focused Repetitive Behavior, meaning that the person’s habitual actions have the potential to cause harm to their body or physical appearance. It shares similar attributes to Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD)—sufferers take part in ritualistic, repetitive behavior, often brought on by a need or urge to do so. The difference between the two is that people with a skin picking disorder find pleasure in their actions and those with OCD don’t. Dermatillomania is also very closely linked to another disorder known as trichotillomania, or compulsive hair pulling. People can pick just about anywhere on their body—face, hands, scalp, back, legs, fingers, feet, cuticles, etc. While there is usually one place that someone with SPD focuses their energy on, if that area becomes too sore or damaged, they will migrate to another part of the body until their main spot has healed. While the default tool for picking is the fingernails, sufferers will also use tools like tweezers and scissors.

Regardless of where or how someone picks, it’s important to remember that dermatillomania is a disorder—it’s not something that the sufferer can help or control. 

2. Skin picking is similar to/another form of cutting/burning. While there may be compulsive tendencies in someone who cuts themselves or burns their skin, the difference is that they want to feel the pain inflicted on them in order to take away emotional trauma. Skin pickers disassociate themselves with the pain in order to complete the “mission” that their brain has fixated on. It isn’t about the pain—it’s about satisfying the urge. For some pickers, looking down at their hands and seeing blood without even realizing they’ve been picking is a common occurrence. This is why pickers can often tear, gnaw, scratch, and dig at a spot for long periods of time, causing bleeding or serious pain, and not stop. Their brain has decided that it’s far more important to finish the “mission” and satisfy the urge than to stop on account of the pain or blood.

3. People who have an SPD are on drugs. Nope. While the effects of usage for drugs like meth may involve picking away at imaginary bugs or other supposed invaders, their need to do so disappears once the effort of the drug wears off. SPD sufferers do not lose their urge. Their need to pick can come from various other sources, but a set cause is unknown. Most people have an underlying anxiety or depression disorder, but not all. For some people, it’s a compulsion that has come about from outside stressors or is the result of someone who is unable to cope with things in their life, such as big changes. During times of stress, strong emotion, or boredom, pickers are more prone to dive into their habit. But this is not the result of a drug problem. 

4. People who pick their skin and leave marks do it for attention. Just as with any other mental or emotional illness, there are people out there who seek to gain attention or affirmation by exploiting such disorders. But for the vast majority of us, there is nothing glamorous about dermatillomania. I would personally love to have all of my toenails and long thumbnails, be able to go to sleep without getting caught up in picking, and wash my hands without discomfort. It’s not about the resulting disfiguring that makes us pick—it’s all about that urge. In the moment, it doesn’t matter that we’re bleeding or the area is already scarred. Even if our actions didn’t result in disfigurement, we would still pick.

Not to mention that people’s general reaction to seeing the site of a picking episode is something along the lines of, “Oh my gosh, what happened to your face/hands/back/arms/etc??? It looks awful!” This draws attention to ourselves and makes us feel an incredible amount of shame and guilt because we know that the inflicted damage has been done by our own hands. It isn’t pleasant and it isn’t fun.

5. People with an SPD can stop whenever they want. As I mentioned before, dermatillomania is a disorder and not something the sufferer can control. It isn’t about breaking a habit. The worst thing you can do for someone with an SPD is to yell at them to stop or try to inhibit their picking session. Calling them out brings attention to their actions and makes them feel ashamed, while not allowing them to pick increases their levels of anxiety because you’re preventing them from satisfying that urge. Both of these things only make the problem worse (not to mention they may resent you after the fact for it), and could result in a more rigorous and damaging picking session later on. The best thing you can do for an SPD sufferer is to just love them as they are. Be their friend, support them if they are feeling down, and encourage them to seek treatment.

6. There’s no treatment for an SPD. The good news is that there are ways to treat and cope with dermatillomania, the most common and effective one being Cognitive Behavioral Therapy which includes Habit Reversal Therapy and Stimulus Control. Anti-depressant medications can also be used to help lessen the severity of the urges. There are even support groups dedicated to helping and supporting sufferers. TLC (Trichotillomania Learning Center, not the television network) has a program called Hands-Down-A-Thon that those who pick their skin and pull their hair can take part in. While it's highly resistant to treatment, it is still possible to control the urges and reduce the amount of picking that takes place.

You can look up more information at TLC's website here. There's also a website called Stop Picking that has activities and suggestions to help sufferers manage their urges here.

Those are some of the big ones. Hopefully now people will grow to have a greater understanding of what it means to have this disorder and, if they have loved ones or friends that suffer from it, they will continue to love and encourage them despite the daily battle.

Friday, March 7, 2014

What I Learned From Taking Two Years of French Classes




Most of the people that know me, including friends, family, and classmates, will say that I’ve spent well above my fair share of time complaining about the fact that I am required to take two full years of a foreign language as a part of my core curriculum for my degree. As an English Major, I always felt that this was unnecessary. I am a student of the English language, not of French or Spanish or German. I didn’t come to college so that I could spend four semesters sitting in a classroom suffering through verb conjugations, vocabulary, and whole knew sets of grammar rules. I did that enough in high school. But as it were, I happen to be in the process of achieving my Bachelor of Arts—meaning that, even though my focus is on English, I’m stuck taking math, science, and foreign languages classes because my degree is essentially a liberal arts degree and encompasses more than one subject of study.

And perhaps my frustration with the idea of taking so many foreign language classes stems from the fact that I am not good at learning them. I took three years of Spanish in high school and, today, could barely have a three-minute conversation with a native speaker at best. I only got A’s in my first two classes because I had easy teachers that graded based on completion and participation. I dragged my heels through every required class and the minute I finished what I needed, I dropped foreign language from my mind, thinking I would never have to deal with it again.

So when I came to college and found out that I had to study French, Spanish, or German, I wanted to bang my head on the wall and cry out of frustration. I wanted to take Spanish, since I had experience with it, but after looking at the classes before registering, I realized that my chance of getting into a Spanish class was slim. German was only offered every other semester, and I didn’t want to spend my entire four years of college taking it. So, I was left with French. 

My first class ended up very much the way I thought it would: I stumbled out with a C thanks to the generosity of our teaching assistant and learned next to nothing. But then my second semester rolled around and I happened to pick a professor who taught the class in a way that worked well for me: It was structured, activity-based, engaging, and she liked to do lots of pantomime when speaking, which only helped to increase my understanding (I am a visual and kinesthetic learner).  Over the course of the following year, I found myself no longer dreading French class and actually becoming interested in what it was that we were learning. I took a History of the English Language class which helped me to  not only understand where my own language came from, but that French is actually more connected to English than we think.
With that in mind, here are some things that I learned from taking three semesters of French:

French is hard. As I said before, I’m terrible when it comes to comprehending and applying foreign languages. I can conjugate verbs all day long, but speaking casually strikes me dumb every single time. French itself is a challenging language because it isn’t very phonetic—most of the last letters or groups of letters in their words are not pronounced. For example, the verb “parler,” to speak, would be conjugated as “parle, parles, parle, parlent” for “I, you, he/she/it, and they,” respectively. You know how they’re all pronounced? “Parl.” Just like that. I can’t explain why this happens, but it takes a long time to get used to it. Their sounds are also very nasal, which isn’t often found in English, and therefore their vowels sound much different to us. “Je,” for “I” is pronounced more like “Juh,” than “jee” or “jay.” 

William the Conqueror
French is, in large part, where our connection to Latin comes from. The Norman Invasion of England brought about the introduction of the language to native English speakers in, well, England. An Anglo-Norman dialect, which was a northern dialect of Old French, became common amongst the nobility and very few people learned to speak English, not even William the Conqueror, the guy who was responsible for the invasion. However, the poor and other classes of people that relied heavily on trading between the two peoples began to integrate French words into English, and in some cases, it’s likely that many were bilingual. French itself is a Romance language, which means that it was a decedent of Latin. The French words that were added to our lexicon are the source of most of our Latin roots.

There are a lot of cognates in French. As anyone who has taken a foreign language will know, there are often times where a word in another language bears a strong resemblance to an English word. English has the unique quality of being a bit of mutt—it’s blending of Romantic and Germanic histories gives us a massive vocabulary, one of the largest in the world. Here are some examples of just a few French cognates:

Commencer (to commence or begin)
Dormir (to sleep; be “dormant”)
Finir (to finish)
Ètudier (to study)
Fumer (to smoke)
Lever (to get up; “levitate”)
beige 
bible
absence
accent
adolescent
applicable
attention
le campus
la cigarette
le crime
la culture
le film
gourmet
pardon
bleu (blue)
aimable (friendly; amiable)
beau (beautiful)
l’estomac (stomach)
du bœuf (beef)
du poulet (chicken)
la glace (ice/ice cream)
comprendre (to understand)

And the list goes on. There are literally thousands of French/English cognates, many of them spelled the exact same way (but pronounced differently). This makes vocabulary often easy to grasp, but the matter of applying it can be a bit more complicated. It’s also interesting to think of the French words as the origin of many English root words. 

You don’t truly learn a language until you envelope yourself in it. This is why so many teachers and professors stress to their students that studying abroad is important. There is no better way to become fluent in another language than to actively be speaking with people who have it as their native tongue. When you learn a language in a classroom setting, it’s giving you the bare basics to begin the real understanding. Many times, the concepts you learn in class are extremely formal and not used on a casual, day-to-day basis by native speakers.

Case in point: The way you say something negative in French is “ne + conjugated verb + pas.” While this is still one-hundred percent acceptable, I found out in my History of the English Language class that many casual French speakers are dropping the “pas” and only saying the “ne.” In a formal paper, this probably wouldn’t be acceptable, but in everyday conversation, it’s becoming more common. That’s something you would never be taught in a standard language class (this particular point was not only not made in my French class, but it was a side note spawned by a completely different conversation about something in English).  

French is beautiful. Two or three years ago, I would have laughed if you told me that French was either pretty or fun to listen to. Now, my perspective has changed. Sure, their sounds are far more nasal than ours and spending a long time speaking in French can make your entire nasal cavity hurt, but listening to someone speak in another language than your own is not only cool, but it’s beautiful. Language is one of the things that make the world so diverse and amazing. Limiting yourself to just your own language takes away your opportunity to appreciate the way people in another part of the world communicate. Before I took a French class, I thought that we all essentially spoke the same words in the same way, just with a different vocabulary—but that’s not the case. Each language has its own rules, grammar, and sentence structure that make it differ from any other. And that individuality is what makes language amazing.

English is beautiful. I never really took the time to think about my own language on a regular basis. It’s something that becomes so ingrained in you, such a part of your daily life that you don’t even think about looking at objectively. But when you sit back and begin to see just how English is structured, how parts of speech and intonation and inflection all play a part in constructing just one sentence, it’s awesome. You gain a new appreciation for what you speak that trickles down into appreciating your own identity. English may not be the prettiest sounding language, but it’s definitely unique.

Taking a foreign language class is worth it. In spite of all the tests, all of the studying, all of the homework and bad grades and long classes and expensive textbooks, I’d still say that it’s a good idea for anyone to take some time to look at another language. Even if it isn’t in the classroom setting, browsing the web or watching a movie in French or Spanish or German or whatever only adds to your understanding of the world. Studying another language IS studying your own. And knowledge for knowledge’s sake is better than a high GPA.

Sunday, February 16, 2014

In Defense of the Disney Princess & Real Feminism


(Before I begin this article, I would like to say that I did, in fact, enjoy Frozen. There were many things about it that were fun and well-done. But for a movie that had so much potential, it frustrates me that I didn't walk out of the theatre in love with it and that Americans are deeming it such a step forward for women in film.)

I’ve written previously about Frozen in another blog post back in January, but there’s another issue I’d like to discuss that, really, doesn’t have much to do with the film itself, but has come up because of it.

Feminism.

Now, before anyone loses their hair or lunch, I’m not “anti-feminist.” But I think we need to understand what exactly “feminism” means, because people have decided to take this word and transform it into some kind of ugly monster that now makes the very mention of it polarizing. In reality, feminism is not something that should be heavily debated, nor should it induce such heavy rage as it seems to whenever someone dare utter the word.

By definition feminism is: 
“The doctrine advocating social, political, and all other rights of women equal to those of men.” 
Equality. Really, that’s all that feminism is about: Treating women with the same respect and dignity that men give each other. It is NOT the idea that women are better than men, more important, more valuable, more intelligent, more anything. And it does NOT undercut the value of men or ignore the fact that men and women are created differently from one another. We are. Men and women are different both intrinsically and biologically, and there is ample evidence to suggest that this is not a debatable issue. However, regardless of what a man can do or a woman can do, we all have the same value.


For example, I love my brothers. One is seventeen and the other thirteen. While they have some things in common, you would be hard-pressed to tell me that they were essentially the same person and could do anything that the other could do. The younger one is driven, clever, and a natural peace-keeper. The older one is comical, responsible, and private when it comes to his personal issues. While you could argue that they are both extroverts and get along well with one another and the people around them, there’s no way that they are “the same.” However, this doesn’t mean that my parents or I consider one or the other more valuable. They are both wonderful because they are people. Human beings. And no matter how much one of them kicks and screams, they cannot change who they are.

For the purposes of this article, I'm going to refer to the infamous Mary Wollstonecraft and her book A Vindication of the Rights of Women, which is often used to demonstrate how the long-considered Mother of Modern Feminism thought that men are evil or have always been tyrannical in nature, suppressing women and keeping them from their potential. And if you only bothered to read those quotes, then yes, it would be logical to assume that Wollstonecraft felt that way about men and believed in the uprising of women and their power.

Except she didn’t.

For every (out of context) quote that people toss around, there are double the amount of quotes describing how she did not view the male gender as inferior or the female gender as superior. Wollstonecraft’s entire point of Rights of Women was that men and woman are equals, are friends, and have the same intrinsic value. She criticized both sides for perpetuating the subjugation of women: men for treating women like they had no real capacity to think, and women for not doing anything to argue otherwise. Not to mention she also wrote an article that coincided with Rights of Women: A Vindication of the Rights of Men. She wanted everyone, not just some men or some women, to have a thorough education so that society would grow and flourish. She saw it very much in a stagnant, beginning-to-decay kind of way because of the perpetuation of foolish ideologies such as the natural inferiority of women. They weren’t just bad for women; they were bad for everyone.

Here are some quotes from Rights of Women to emphasize my point:

“I do not wish them [women] to have power over men; but over themselves.”

Wollstonecraft wanted women to take charge of themselves and their lives, rather than sit back and let a man do everything for them. She didn’t believe that men were better, or that they should rule over women like tyrannical dictators. She wanted women to recognize their own potential and take charge of who they are, rather than sit back and let their husbands do everything for them.

"Were women more rationally educated, could they take a more comprehensive view of things, they would be contented to love but once in their lives; and after marriage calmly let passion subside into friendship—into that tender intimacy, which is the best refuge from care; yet is built on such pure, still affections, that idle jealousies would not be allowed to disturb the discharge of the sober duties of life, nor to engross the thoughts that ought to be otherwise employed."

And here’s another criticism of women—far too often, women believed that the same passion and exuberance they experienced during courtship would last through their marriage. Then, when it inevitably fizzled and the man may have turned out to be a bit of a floozy, the woman was left bored and uninterested, leading to things like extramarital affairs to try and regain that passion they once had with their husband. Wollstonecraft argues here that marriage is a strong friendship, rather than a fondness. The husband and wife should have things in common and actually enjoy the other’s company. She also points out that rational thought leads to contentment—woman would no longer feel like they needed to love more than once, suggesting that she was a supporter of solid, happy marriages that lasted.

And for the sake of space and time, I won’t continue. But with these points in mind, let us take a look at where Frozen, and by association its fandom, begins to get on my nerves.

It was out of fashion, anyway.

It was out of fashion, anyway.
For whatever reason, there seems to be a massive backlash against the “Disney Princess” image. With the onset of “Modern Feminism,” people seem to enjoy poking fun at the Disney Princess lineup, its themes, characters, story lines, and just about anything that doesn’t fit into the “modern” perspective on the world. Disney has even started taking shots at itself with films like Enchanted, openly stating clichés or making obvious jokes that the audience is meant to laugh at and go, “Oh yeah, remember THOSE archaic views? Look how far we’ve come!"

Except, have we really?

As a society, we have become so obsessed with the idea of representing females as strong, independent characters that we’ve begun to lose sight of what it is that makes a character such things. Rather than focus on simply making them people, we’ve turned them into she-men with the exact same stereotypes and sucked all the individuality out of them. A woman can no longer just be a woman; she has to be a strong, independent woman that “don’t need no man” to complete her. That’s become our modern definition of “feminism."

Frozen is one of the biggest culprits of this way of thinking. While I enjoyed the film visually and thought it had some of the best comedy of any of their films, there were so many moments that I wanted to chuck my popcorn at the screen because I got so damn sick of hearing some variation of the phrase “You’re marrying someone you just met” uttered every ten minutes. I feel like most of the film went out of its way to buck a stereotype that we seem hell-bent on insisting exists. Disney doesn’t add that stuff into their movies because they’re “socially progressive;” they do it because that’s what puts people’s butts in the theatre seats. That’s what people want to see—the constant, habitual, uninterrupted lambasting of Disney and their rich history of beautiful films that, by the way, were the most successful when they weren’t focused on producing “feminist” characters.

Let’s look at Elsa, who has become the quintessential example of the feminist ideology: She’s the beautiful, albeit mentally and socially disturbed, queen of Arendelle. She spends the majority of her life locked away in her room, forced to hide herself and her powers from everyone, even her sister (because you know, us women have always been subjected to being locked away where no one could get to us!). When it comes time for her coronation, she exhibits more fear than anything else which, given the circumstances, is justified. But instead of sucking it up and dealing, or even offering to re-open the lines of communication with Anna who could possibly help her not only understand her power, but learn to cope with it, Elsa chooses instead to hide behind her fear. When her powers are revealed by a frustrated Anna to a large portion of the kingdom, she runs away and abandons her duties as queen to live in isolation in the mountains, doing nothing except singing and looking pretty.

 
How exactly is this “feminist?” Come to think of it, her actions and personality sound more like the antithesis of Wollstonecraft’s feminist. She’s weak, selfish, incapable of standing up for herself, isolating, and thoughtless. The person who is supposed to run her kingdom with pride and dignity instead spends most of the film cowering in a pretty, empty ice castle like a wet, shivering Chihuahua. With sexy heels.

But hey. That song is catchy.


I get the message that Disney was trying to send. I really do: The idea was to be free from fear and anxiety and to let go of everything that holds you back so you can live your life. But if Elsa really wanted to do that, why did it require her to run away from all of her responsibilities, her sister (who is the only remaining member of their family besides herself), and her kingdom? That isn’t rising above circumstances; that’s running like hell away from them. Not to mention she won’t even let Anna talk to her when she comes to the castle. The sister that braves treacherous snow storms and wilderness just to reconcile their relationship and knock some sense into Elsa so she can save their kingdom from inevitable destruction is shoved aside for fear that she could be hurt. Is it a valid fear? Sure. But the fact that three-fourths of the way through the movie this is happening doesn’t portray a strong character with a wide arc at all. It’s someone who is manipulated and controlled entirely by fear.

Sure, she’s got a character—weak-willed, narrow-minded,  and lonely with a nice face, pretty dress, and absolutely no sense of priorities—but a character nonetheless. And that’s fine. Have someone who is like that and then either dispose of them or give them an arc. Leaving her in the film to fester in her own self-pity and then slapping a “she doesn’t get married in the end” label on her does NOT make her a feminist icon. It makes her even less interesting.

Then of course Anna gets shunned for her stupidity and carelessness when it comes to romance, because every teenage girl is always an expert at relationships, especially when they are deprived socially. Anna continues to be criticized throughout the duration of the movie, with everyone and their brother commenting on how marrying someone you just met is foolish. She’s seen as “weak” because she is engaged to someone in less than twenty-four hours and Elsa is “strong” because she doesn’t? What on earth does that have to do with feminism? If we’re still looking at Wollstonecraft’s model, she never mentions the idea that true feminism requires women to detest quick marriages (or marriage in general) or that to be a feminist character you’re not allowed to want to find true love.

In fact, Anna displays more feminist traits than her sister. Regardless of how ridiculous her decision to marry Hans was and then leave him to control the kingdom while she left, she did something. She took charge and went to find her sister out of love for her and her kingdom. She at least defended her decision to marry Hans, sticking with him until he turned out to be a loser. She saved her sister’s life and sacrificed her own in the process…and Elsa is still the better character because she doesn't want to find love or marry anyone. It makes no sense.

Why should Anna be shunned for the fact that she wants to be married? Why have we, as a society, suddenly decided that the desire to meet “The One” and get married is such a heinous idea? Judging by the number of “dating tips” blog posts I’ve seen, it seems we’re all very much in the same boat as Anna. Why do we villain-ize the romantic attraction young women have towards men, at least in animated movies? Is it because of the time frame it takes to happen?

Let me point out that these are, above all, movies. Children’s movies, specifically, and all of them thrive on simplicity. The simpler the plot and characters, the better. Unlike adults, kids aren’t looking for complex story lines and well-developed characters. They just want to look at a screen and be entertained for ninety minutes. In order to do that, Disney has to cut corners here and there and carefully plan their plots so that they are possible, but not necessarily probable, all while trying to create good characters, update the fairytale, do justice to the original, and market the film to as many people as possible. Falling in love can happen in three days, but is it likely? No. But it’s easier to make a movie that takes place over a shorter time frame because, if not, you have to make up for the missing parts with either transitions (which can be tricky) or exposition (which can be VERY tricky).

If Frozen took place over an extended period of time, the plot would have ended up even clunkier than it was. Besides that, it’s not even clear that Anna and Kristoff are married at the end of the movie. They may have begun to realize their romance is blossoming, but neither of them comes out and says, “I’m madly in love with you, please marry me.” They are, as Wollstonecraft would have described, best friends, if nothing else. The timeline isn’t meant to be realistic, it’s meant to be concise and, at the very least, possible.

And yes, I have known several people who met their significant other and knew that same day that they were meant to be together. Some of them have been married for upwards of thirty or forty years.

But then there’s another question that we could ask: Is it possible to have complex kids’ movies while still keeping a level of simplicity? Yes. Disney’s been doing it for the past seven decades.
Of course, I’m not limiting this realization to Disney Princess films. Ninety percent of the films that the company has put out since Snow White have some layer of depth to them. Here are some examples:

Pinocchio
Bambi
Lady and the Tramp
Dumbo
Alice in Wonderland
Fox and the Hound
Jungle Book
Pocahontas
Lion King
Sword in the Stone
Princess and the Frog
The Little Mermaid
Beauty and the Beast
Aladdin
Mulan
Tarzan

And the list goes on. Most of the time, Disney manages to get some sort of secondary layer to their films, even if it is something that has been beaten to death (like prejudice). But while these films all have some kind of subtext that can be gleaned from them, their focus is on creating story lines and some-what engaging characters, not limiting their leading ladies to stereotypical, card-board cut-outs.

As another blogger pointed out, even in the Princess films, the romance is something that comes secondary to the initial wants of the characters. Every last princess—with the exception of Snow White, Cinderella, and Aurora—begins their tale with a desire to have something, be something, change something, etc. Ariel wanted to see the human world before she came across Eric. “Part of Your World,” the prime example of the “Whining Song,” happens before she even runs into his ship. Belle wants something greater than herself, whatever that might be. She denies Gaston not because he’s a man, but because he’s a self-absorbed jerk. Tiana wants a restaurant because of her close connection to her father and a love of cooking, falling in love with Naveen only after he stops whining about being a frog and starts to pull his own weight. Rapunzel wants to see floating lights and get out of her tower, Mulan wants to save her father’s life and sacrifices her own safety and security in the process, Jasmine wants to escape the constricting life of royalty and be her own person, and Pocahontas just wanted peace. All of these ladies find love only after they begin their adventure to achieve their initial goal. The romance is almost always secondary.

Instead of recognizing plain ol’ good characterization and clear motives that have developed in Disney movies over the past several decades, we’d rather focus on all of the movies that don’t necessarily hit that mark. But even when you look at films like Cinderella or Sleeping Beauty—two of the most common films that get beat with the Sexist Stick—you can see that Disney opted for simplicity in the storytelling and the characters in order to make room for the stunning animation which, at the time, was all done by hand and took lots of blood, sweat and tears to produce (not that current films don’t, but hand-drawn films will always be more impressive to me). Not to mention that these were made in 1950 (Cinderella) and 1959 (Sleeping Beauty), at a time when culture was drastically different, and that neither of these movies were original material. They came from fairy tales that were passed around for centuries, all over the world, by women. 

And I think that, with all of this outrage over the themes and characters and sexism and improbability of story lines, we are only making things worse for our kids. Children are not born with sexist ideas. They’re raised to see them. And when we sit down and tell our daughters that “Disney is bad because they don’t make good female characters and you should always watch movies that strip women of any lady features because that’s weakness,” we’re the ones creating the problem.

Bill Cosby was once quoted, after being asked what would be the best way to stop racism, as saying, “Stop talking about it.” His point was, essentially, race is an issue because we continually talk about it and make it an issue. The same thing applies to feminism. When we spend all of our time trying to tiptoe over the issue or slam it in people’s faces, we’re only exacerbating the problem and creating a larger divide. Why do female characters have to be labeled “strong?” Why can’t they just be “female?” Why do we have to marginalize the role and qualities of men just to make women look stronger? That isn’t equality, that’s a problem. And it certainly isn’t feminism.

We’re not giving our kids enough credit. Even in a day and age when everything has the potential to be “offensive,” kids are still rational creatures. Watching a movie isn’t going to make them suddenly transform them into an air head. Sure, when they’re little they may think in simpler terms, but that changes when you get older. You grow. You learn. You analyze and develop opinions on your own.

Case in point: When I was little, my family had VHS’s of both The Little Mermaid and Cinderella. I remember that each day I would get up, grab the VHS, and would watch Cinderella over and over and over and over again. All day long, for weeks straight. I did the same thing with The Little Mermaid a few years later. Why? Because I liked the movies. That’s it. No other reason. In fact, my strongest memory of either of those films was the scene where the stepmother locks Cinderella in her room and Lucifer tries to keep the mice from letting her out, as well as when Triton destroys Ariel’s collection of human artifacts. I remember those scenes because they moved me—I was so angry that the stepmother was so mean and that Triton could be so heartless towards his daughter.

You know what I don’t remember?

The sexism. The shallow characters. The forcing of men and women stereotypes on everything. I didn’t remember those things because I was five and I didn’t give two dog turds that Cinderella fell in love with a man she met once or that everything about her character looks vapid and uninteresting from modern day standards. I thought the mice were cute and Ariel was pretty.

I didn’t grow up to be an irrational, dim-witted floozy. I fully recognize that beauty is on the inside and that people falling in love in two days isn’t realistic. I have not been tainted or transformed by a few dozen children’s movies, and chances are, neither will any other child. As a parent, it’s your responsibility to teach your son or daughter that their value is found on the inside—not Disney’s.

So leave the Disney Princesses alone and relax. Enjoy the movies for what they are, and stop trying to force a feminist ideology on characters. Let them be people—let them be human beings. When you shoot for anything else, you’re bound to simply fall flat.